Released: April 1972
Chart Peak: #70
Weeks Charted: 27
Fleetwood Mac's last two records, Kiln House and Future Games, have between them provided me with perhaps a hundred hours of enjoyment. And that's the ultimate test of a record's worth. Personally, I was never interested in early Fleetwood Mac, the British blues band; but this Fleetwood Mac has little in common with that group except for the drums and rhythm section of Mick Fleetwood and John McVie. The closest thing I can think of to the kind of music the new Mac plays is moody rock of the middle-period Beatles. Kiln House is similar to Beatles '65 in its dual concerns with vintage rock 'n' roll and muted, romantic pieces. Jeremy Spencer took care of the former area, while Danny Kirwan extended the style best represented by McCartney's "I'll Follow the Sun."
Since Spencer left, the band has been forced to re-orient itself somewhat: Kirwan has become the sole focal figure, and this central role has forced him to deal in the visceral as well as the moody areas. But Kirwan had already shown on Kiln House that he was well equipped to handle both. His "Jewel Eyed Judy," "Tell Me All the Things You Do," and "Station Man" are among the best examples of the soft-hard rock song, with their lovely, silky vocals and smoking guitars. If Kiln House holds up somewhat better than the gentler Future Games, Kirwan's dynamic songs are at least as responsible as Spencer's presence on the former album.
Bare Trees falls somewhere between the last two Fleetwood Macs; that is, it hits harder than Future Games, but its concerns are much more introspective than those of Kiln House. Kirwan has written two melancholic, really elegiac songs based on the bittersweet poem of an elderly woman, "Thoughts on a Grey Day," that closes the album. The first song, "Bare Trees," its title suggested by a line from old Mrs. Scarrot's poem, moves along exhilaratingly, even though its lyric is a metaphor of age and approaching death; perhaps it's the acceptance of the cycle that gives the music a hopeful, almost happy feeling. The second, "Dust," is a great deal more somber, but it retains Kirwan's deft melodic touch, manifesting itself in both the sighing vocal and in the guitar lines that sweep softly alongside it. "Dust" sets the stage for the poem, which is similar in effect to the "Voices of Old People" track on Simon & Garfunkel's Bookends. The group has thoughtfully preceded the poem with about 15 seconds of silence, sufficient time to pick up the tone arm if you're not in the mood.
As before, it's Danny Kirwan who makes the difference. There's nothing on Bare Trees to equal "Station Man" and "Jewel Eyed Judy," but, aside from "Dust," Kirwan's songs here rock much more than his Future Games material did. He really lets loose on "Danny's Chant," which features tough-guy electric guitar sounds purely for their own sake. His "Child of Mine" is a lyrically disjointed but musically forthright rock 'n' roll song. And Kirwan's instrumental, "Sunny Side of Heaven," shows off his unique electric guitar style to good advantage. Like most outstanding guitarists, Kirwan gets a sound that is more plainly human than mechanical. His guitar tone is piercing but tremendous -- powerful but at the same time plaintive, especially in the upper ranges.
With his multiple skills, Kirwan can't help being the focal point. It is his presence that makes Fleetwood Mac something more than another competent rock group. He gives them a distinctiveness, a sting. He makes you want to hear these songs again.
- Bud Scoppa, Rolling Stone, 6/8/72.
Fleetwood Mac, despite several personnel changes, has remained one of the most consistently excellent British rock bands. Danny Kirwan's vocals are full of delightful little flourishes, while the other members of the band are most accomplished. They're not into ear-breaking hard rock, but rather set moods that are subtly relaxing, quietly meaningful. Outstanding are "Child of Mine," "Bare Trees" and "Danny's Chant."
- Billboard, 1972.
The long winter seems to be over for Fleetwood Mac with this, their second release in less than six months. Ever since the grafting on of new limb Bob Welch, their tree has been budding and swaying to a smooth rock sound. This album bears the fruit of Welch's writing talents, as well as a couple of juicy Christine McVie tunes, and some of Danny Kirwan's ripest music in several years. It's good to see a top-notch band in full bloom again.
- Steve Ditlea, Circus, 7/72.
Their new identity is ominously mellow, but at least this time it's recognizable, and they've upped the speed a little. A lot less muddled than Future Games and occasionally as rich as Kiln House, but so thoroughly homogenized that it's hard to remember exactly how the cream tasted once it's gone down. B+
- Robert Christgau, Christgau's Record Guide, 1981.
This band has gone through more cycles than a modern microwave oven. Bare Trees comes from what might loosely be defined as their middle period (post-Peter Green, pre-Lindsey Buckingham/Stevie Nicks), when Christine Perfect McVie's voice and keyboards brought a more defined pop sensibility to their work. It is also among the best releases of this period, highlighted by the enduring "Sentimental Lady." The original Reprise CD's sound is obviously compressed, somewhat murky, and affected by hiss. B-
- Bill Shapiro, Rock & Roll Review: A Guide to Good Rock on CD, 1991.
On Bare Trees, Fleetwood Mac married the gritty electric blues-rock of their earlier incarnations to the classic pop sensibilities that would later become fully realized in 1975's Fleetwood Mac. Bob Welch's "Sentimental Lady" and Christine McVie's soulful "Spare Me a Little of Your Love" are highlights. Danny Kirwin revealed an ability to compose highly melodic material that didn't constrain the band's legendary musical chemistry. * * * *
- Rick Clark, The All-Music Guide to Rock, 1995.
Main Page | The Classic 500 | Readers' Favorites | Other Seventies Discs | Search The RockSite/The Web