Prisoner In Disguise
Asylum 7E 1045
Released: September 1975
Chart Peak: #4
Weeks Charted: 28
Certified Gold: 10/8/75
Prisoner in Disguise is an attempt to re-create the enormous critical and commercial success of Ronstadt's 1974 album, Heart like a Wheel. Unfortunately, while every choice on the previous album seemed inspired, these are largely pedestrian. As a parallel work, Prisoner operates at a distinct disadvantage to Heart; track by track, it is thoroughly and transparently inferior.
Part of the problem is Ronstadt's voice, a truly remarkable instrument which she has never learned to control. Ronstadt's long suit has never been her skill as an interpreter -- she is easily capable of misunderstanding even so straightforward a lyric as "Tracks of My Tears" -- and, where Peter Asher and Andrew Gold's arrangements on the earlier album made up for her failures of comprehension, here, on a much more difficult set of songs, they simply can't compensate.
But even on material which is better suited to her voice, Ronstadt fails. For instance, her country classic for Prisoner is Dolly Parton's "I Will Always Love You," which is neither easy to sing (as was Hank Williams's "I Can't Help It [If I'm Still in Love With You]" on the earlier album) nor unidentified with another singer's version. Ronstadt and Parton have similar voices and Ronstadt likes to play that up, but she lacks the distinctiveness of Parton's upper range. Similarly, while Ronstadt turned in a first-rate performance on Lowell George's renegade country classic "Willin'" on Wheel, she fills the niche here with his notably inferior "Roll Um Easy."
Although the success of Heart like a Wheel seemed to contradict it, my strongest impression of Linda Ronstadt, after hearing Prisoner in Disguise, is that she has a great voice and almost no idea of what to do with it. It's time for her producer and arranger to come up with a new approach.
- Dave Marsh, Rolling Stone, 11/20/75.
Miss Ronstadt is fast on her way to becoming the best and most versatile contemporary female vocalist. Like most of the "overnight sensations" in the record business she has spent a decade recording and years before that in the clubs to reach her current status. Yet she is now at the point where she can handle a country melody, old soul rocker or ballad, a straight rocker, or a number of tunes that defy categorization with no ascertainable difficulty. Whether the songs are chosen by the singer or producer Peter Asher, the taste is nearly impeccable, with material from the likes of Dolly Parton, Jimmy Cliff, Neil Young, James Taylor, and the great Motown catalog. Asher's production is superb, but the star is Miss Ronstadt, who seems remarkably at home in whatever music she chooses to sing. This is most noticeable in country, where she seems totally comfortable. Hard to find a flaw here, on this simply handled (vocally and instrumentally), yet complex album. Best cuts: "Love Is A Rose," "Tracks Of My Tears," "Prisoner In Disguise," "Heat Wave," "The Sweetest Gift," "I Will Always Love You," "Silver Blue."
- Billboard, 1975.
I agree that this is a letdown after Heart Like a Wheel, but I wish someone could tell me why. Maybe the explanations are vague -- she's repeating a formula, she's not putting out, etc. -- because a singer like Ronstadt, who specializes in interpreting good songs rather than projecting a strong persona, must achieve an ineffable precision to succeed. But maybe it's simpler than that. People say her versions of "Tracks of My Tears" and "Heat Wave" are weak, but they're not -- they simply don't match the too familiar originals. "When Will I Be Loved?" and "You're No Good," on the other hand, were great songs half-remembered, kicking off each side of Heart Like a Wheel with a jolt to the memory. And this album could sure use a jolt of something. B
- Robert Christgau, Christgau's Record Guide, 1981.
Linda Ronstadt followed the commercial and critical breakthrough success of Heart Like A Wheel with Prisoner in Disguise, a record that essentially repeated the formula of its predecessor. While it lacked the consistency of Heart Like A Wheel, it was a thoroughly enjoyable, highlighted by sturdy remakes of the Motown classics "Tracks of My Tears" and "Heat Wave." * * * *
- Stephen Thomas Erlewine, The All-Music Guide to Rock, 1995.
Heart Like a Wheel and Prisoner in Disguise exemplify Peter Asher's influential production style and Ronstadt's emotional brand of country-rock. In the poignant title tunes, memorable duets with Emmylou Harris and carefully chosen remakes (such as Smokey Robinson and the Miracles' "Tracks of My Tears"), Ronstadt successfully walks the line dividing sadness from sappiness. * * * * *
- Elizabeth Lynch, Musichound Rock: The Essential Album Guide, 1996.
Main Page | Readers' Favorites | The Classic 500 | Other Seventies Discs | Search The RockSite/The Web