"But Seriously, Folks..."
Released: May 1978
Chart Peak: #8
Weeks Charted: 27
Certified Platinum: 8/7/78
Joe Walsh seemed an odd choice as Eagle-come-lately because he has a sense of humor; he's a mensch, not an Übermensch. Presumably, Henley, Frey & Co. wanted him for his guitar playing. Walsh added enormous punch to Hotel California -- he's the one who kicks "Life in the Fast Lane" into fifth gear -- but good as that album was, it hardly left room for Walsh's bizarre brand of self-depreciation. For that, he has to make his own records.
"But Seriously, Folks..." -- whose jacket pictures Walsh relaxing at a cafe that is unremarkable except for the fact that it's underwater -- is a triumph in the grand tradition of So What? and You Can't Argue with a Sick Mind. (Since Walsh is now signed to Asylum, shouldn't he have called the new disc Voluntary Commitment, or something like that?) The sound is full of brilliant highlights, and the songs are good, though not as carefully written as Pete Townshend's, with whom Walsh shares a lot, and not as lazy as Jimmy Buffett's, with whom Walsh shares too much. On the other hand, not having to try very hard is pretty much what the album is about -- "Theme from Boat Weirdos," a delightful instrumental, comes off like a backing track for which Walsh couldn't be bothered to find lyrics -- and what makes Walsh's celebration of ease so much fun is that he's never arrogant. He's befuddled, but he won't look a gift horse in the mouth -- a phrase that might well turn up as the title of his next LP.
- Greil Marcus, Rolling Stone, 8/10/78.
Walsh, the fiery Eagles guitarist, goes solo here with an array of arresting rock'n'roll. He gets support from fellow Eagles Glenn Frey, Don Felder, Don Henley and Timothy Schmit as they contribute both background vocals and instrumentation, and there are some Eagles-like textures to the album. But the basic unit of Walsh on guitar and synthesizer, Joe Vitale on drums, percussion, flute and synthesizer, Jay Ferguson on keyboards, Willie Weeks on bass and Joey Murcia on guitar produces a distinctive sound -- harder edged and more guitar-oriented, playing off Walsh's scorching vocals. Best cuts: "Over And Over," "Second Hand Store," "Indian Summer," "Tomorrow," "Life's Been Good."
- Billboard, 1978.
Well, "Second Hand Store" is fairly likable, but keep it to yourself -- a follow-up would ruin everything. "Life's Been Good" is not only Summer Song '78, it was born to be a novelty one-shot, and that it happens to say more about the tribulations of stardom than all the concept albums ever devised on the subject just goes to show how deeply significant AM radio can be. C+
- Robert Christgau, Christgau's Record Guide, 1981.
This is his biggest solo success, featuring the hit "Life's Been Good." * * * *
- Kub Coda, The All-Music Guide to Rock, 1995.
Humor dominates on But Seriously, Folks... -- presumably because Walsh's more serious music was being made with the Eagles -- but at least the jokes, particularly "Life's Been Good," are funny. * * *
- Gary Graff, Musichound Rock: The Essential Album Guide, 1996.
Main Page | Readers' Favorites | The Classic 500 | Other Seventies Discs | Search The RockSite/The Web