Released: May 1970
Chart Peak: #1
Weeks Charted: 68
Certified Gold: 5/22/70
It took eight months to untangle, but the documentary three album set containing the sounds from Woodstock is out on Atlantic Records distributed on its Cotillion label, and its executives did all the legwork, although only one of their artists are featured, namely Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young.
Producer Eric Blackstead, who was in charge of the sound at the festival itself, edited the album from one hundred hours of tape. The artists appearing in the film are the same on the record with the exception of the Jefferson Airplane, the Butterfield Blues Band, and Canned Heat who appear on the disc and not on the screen. Also included, of course, are the documentary aspects of the event, such as Hugh Romney, leader of the Hog Farm, P.A. announcements and such.
The album is revolutionary in almost every way. it is truly a deluxe package. The only drawback is the price, it will cost you over fifteen dollars to buy it. The price in is line with the amount of work that went into the production.
When asked if the three records would ever be broken up and sold as iundividual single albums, Wexler replied, "If we sell out, really sell out, maybe we'll think about it."
- Circus, 7/70.
"I left one thing out of my Woodstock article," says Tom Smucker, author of a good one. "I left out how boring it was." And though you can be sure it's not like being there, this three-record set does capture that. As is inevitable in a live album featuring stage announcements, crowd noises, and sixteen different artists, not one side is enjoyable straight through: CSNY are stiff and atrociously flat in their second gig, Paul Butterfield sounds wasted, Sha Na Na should never record, Joan Baez should never record, and so forth. But a substantial proportion of this music sounds pretty good, and three performances belong to history: Ten Years After's "I'm Going Home" (speed kills), Joe Cocker's "With a Little Help from My Friends" (mad Englishman), and Jimi Hendrix's "Star Spangled Banner" (wotta ham). Also, the stage announcements and crowd noises are better than most. B
- Robert Christgau, Christgau's Record Guide, 1981.
(Woodstock/Woodstock II) More aural history than concert recording. To say that it's all here would obviously be a literal overstatement -- the festival ran for over three days (and these selections were drawn from seventy-two hours of recorded tape). But after listening to the three hours and forty-six minutes of music as well as the now-infamous stage announcements, it's as close as one is going to get two decades after the fact. It's worthwhile to remember that the 400,000 who were a part of this event were representatives of the last real people's revolution this nation has experienced. Impossible as it now seems, they and countless others like them really did stop the Vietnam War. Woodstock was the first great sixties event, the first mega be-in, and no one was prepared for the human outpouring to which it bore musical witness. Soundwise, what you get is the magic moment and the faux pas that make this more concert verité than musical pinnacle -- it was really a question of who was there and why, rather than what they played or heard. This CD package captures that as well as it can now be done, but you won't play this one for its sound quality. B
- Bill Shapiro, Rock & Roll Review: A Guide to Good Rock on CD, 1991.
The wrong notes are jarring and the recording flaws seem obvious, but the energy and enthusiasm compensate. * * *
- Bruce Eder, The All-Music Guide to Rock, 1995.
- Entertainment Weekly, 2001.
A historical document on vinyl from the most famous rock concert in the world, this album was recorded live, with accompanying weather, sound glitches and warning about brown acid. Cockeyed, flawed and invaluable for no other reason than as a reflection of the times when R&R could change the world, the landmark grab bag contains some schlock (Sha Na Na?!) but also amazing performances like Jimi Hendrix's noisy, drugged-out version of "The Star Spangled Banner." * * * * *
- Zagat Survey Music Guide - 1,000 Top Albums of All Time, 2003.
(2009 40th Anniversary Limited Edition) The 40th anniversary of Woodstock has, not surprisingly, given birth to a flurry of related products, ranging from CDs by associated artists to an extras-enhanced DVD of Woodstock, the movie. For our money, the best bet is this six-CD box, containing approximately one-fifth of all the festival's music, much of it available for the first time in any format. Arranged chronologically, and featuring songs from almost every act that played (missing in action: The Band and Ten Years After), it's a dandy primer and/or refresher course in why that mythic, muddy lovefest mattered, man.
A key selling point here is the trove of unreleased material, some of it -- three tunes from folkie Bert Sommer, the Grateful Dead's beatific "Dark Star" -- truly breathtaking. Given the mediocrity of many (though hardly all) of the performances from prior Woodstock releases, such gems easily make this the, uh, grooviest-ever distillation of that seminal event. Even so, we can already hear some grizzled completists complaining that Rhino didn't make good on its original plan to collect every scrap of the music on 30 CDs. Get real, tie-dyed daddies: They've gotta save something for the 50th-anniversary blowout, don't they? B
- Tom Sinclair, Entertainment Weekly, 8/14/09.
Main Page | The Classic 500 | Readers' Favorites | Other Seventies Discs | Search The RockSite/The Web